Available to buy here:
Welcome to Beautyistic — where beauty meets brilliance, and truth meets texture. Whether your glam is soft and subtle or bold and bulletproof, one thing we can all agree on? Makeup that stays in place all day is the dream. And when humidity hits or that 3 p.m. shine creeps in, a setting spray can either be your best friend… or a total letdown.
So, let’s talk about the e.l.f. Matte Magic Mist & Set. This is a compact 2.0 fl oz setting spray designed to keep your face and eye makeup looking fresh from morning rush to late-night dinner. It promises a matte finish while also hydrating and soothing the skin — quite the multitasker. The formula includes aloe, green tea, cucumber, and skin-loving vitamins A, C, and E. You can mist it on after your makeup or use it pre-application by spritzing your brush or sponge. It’s lightweight, vegan, cruelty-free, and budget-friendly — classic e.l.f. in philosophy and form.
Now, onto how it actually performs in the real world. I tried this out across a mix of situations — hot outdoor errands, indoor workdays under fluorescent lights, and even a girls’ night out where dancing was involved. I sprayed it after applying my base, and sometimes even before foundation using a damp sponge, just to test its full versatility. Right away, the mist felt fine and cooling — no aggressive squirts or heavy droplets that ruin your makeup.
It dried quickly without that tacky or overly matte feeling some sprays can leave behind. And the finish? Truly matte, but not flat. There’s still life in your skin, but the shine stays under control. My T-zone usually betrays me by mid-day, but with this spray, the oil breakthrough was noticeably delayed — especially when I used it both before and after makeup. By the end of the day, my blush and bronzer still had definition, and creasing around my smile lines was minimal.
That said, let’s talk balance. There are definitely pros and cons here. On the plus side: it’s compact, travel-friendly, super affordable, and delivers a strong matte hold that works beautifully for oily or combo skin. I also love that it doesn’t have a heavy fragrance, which is great for sensitive noses. The skin-soothing ingredients like cucumber and aloe are a nice touch, though I wouldn’t rely on this for serious hydration — it’s more of a skin refresher than a true moisture booster.
Now for the cons: if your skin leans dry, this may not be your best friend. It can emphasize texture if you go overboard, and while the mist is generally fine, the nozzle could be more consistent. On a few occasions, it sputtered slightly, which might mess with precision if you’re not careful.
Is this review helping you out so far? If it is, go ahead and hit like, subscribe, and tap that bell icon. It helps us keep creating honest reviews here at Beautyistic — and it lets the algorithm know beauty lovers deserve the real tea.
As for value for money — e.l.f. continues to be the poster child for quality on a budget. You’re getting solid performance for a fraction of the price of high-end setting sprays, and while it might not have ultra-luxurious packaging or fragrance, it absolutely holds its own in terms of functionality.
Compared to higher-end options like Urban Decay’s All Nighter or the MAC Fix+, e.l.f. Matte Magic Mist & Set does strip back on the bells and whistles, but it delivers where it matters: staying power and mattifying control. The price-to-performance ratio is excellent, especially if your budget’s tight or you’re just starting to build your makeup kit.
The build quality is what you’d expect from e.l.f.— simple plastic, easy to toss in a bag, and lightweight. Nothing fancy, but it gets the job done. I haven’t noticed any formula degradation after weeks of use, and it doesn’t separate or smell funky over time. Longevity-wise, I used it consistently for about three weeks, and the small bottle still isn’t empty — so a little goes a long way.
I didn’t need to reach out to customer service, but e.l.f. has a good reputation for responsive support and a user-friendly website. Plus, their leaping bunny certification and ingredient transparency build extra trust with ingredient-savvy consumers.
If the matte finish feels too drying for your skin type, consider switching to the e.l.f. Dewy Coconut Setting Mist or Milani Make It Last Dewy for more hydration. But if you’re oily-skinned or battling mid-day shine, the Matte Magic version hits the sweet spot.
So, what’s the final word? The e.l.f. Matte Magic Mist & Set does what it promises — controls shine, sets makeup, and offers a comfortable matte finish that actually lasts. It’s not perfect for everyone — drier skin types might want to proceed with caution — but if you’re looking for performance without breaking the bank, this is a solid pick. It’s especially great for oily and combination skin, or anyone who wants a dependable setting spray that doesn’t feel like a splurge.
Thanks for watching and spending time with us here at Beautyistic. You’ll find the purchase link in the description or comments below.
And if you’ve already used this mist, tell us — did it work for you, or was it a miss? Drop your experience in the comments — I’d love to hear how it performed on your skin type.
Thanks for tuning in, and until next time, stay beautiful inside and out!
Available to buy here:
