Available to buy here:
Hey beautiful souls, welcome back to Beautyistic! If you’ve been hunting for a liquid liner that promises precision, intensity, and longevity, I think you’ll want to stick around for this one. We’re taking a closer look at the Stila Stay All Day® Dual-Ended Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner in Intense Black—a product that’s been a staple in many makeup kits, now offered in a sleek dual-ended pen for added convenience.
From the get-go, this liner is all about delivering a bold, matte finish. Each pen holds 0.033 fl. oz of intensely pigmented black liquid, designed to glide on effortlessly while remaining waterproof, smudge-resistant, and long-lasting. The dual-ended design gives you two different tips—one for precise, defined lines and the other for slightly thicker, more dramatic looks—so it’s versatile whether you’re aiming for a subtle day look or a dramatic evening cat-eye.
When I put it to the test, the application was impressively smooth. The fine tip allowed me to draw incredibly sharp lines along my lash line, and I loved how the other end helped me create a bolder wing without needing a separate brush. The formula dried quickly, yet didn’t feel harsh or drying on my eyelids, which is a common issue with some liquid liners. It stayed put all day through my morning routine, a midday coffee run, and even during an unexpected little rain shower—no smudges, no fading, just intense black pigment from start to finish.
Of course, no product is perfect. While the dual tips are convenient, I found that beginners might need a few tries to master the pressure and angle for a flawless line. Also, because it’s intensely pigmented, any mistakes are less forgiving and require careful removal.
On the upside, the pigmentation is rich, the waterproof formula is reliable, and the dual-ended design is genuinely thoughtful for versatility. The pen itself feels sturdy and well-made, which gives you confidence in daily use, and I’d say this is built to last through multiple applications without any issues in the formula drying out prematurely.
Value-wise, it sits in the higher mid-range for liquid liners, but considering the dual tips, the iconic Stila formula, and the performance, I think it’s justified. Compared to other waterproof liquid liners on the market, Stila’s stays ahead for intensity and wear time, though if you’re on a tighter budget, there are good alternatives like L’Oréal or NYX, which deliver decent longevity but may not offer the same precision or dual-tip convenience.
If you’ve been frustrated with liners that fade, smudge, or require constant touch-ups, this pen is a game-changer. And yes, even though it’s marketed for all makeup lovers, I tested it on both my lids and under various conditions to ensure the results hold up in real life.
If you’re finding this review helpful so far, don’t forget to hit that like button, subscribe, and click the bell icon so other beauty lovers can find this video too. Your support truly helps us keep sharing honest reviews like this!
In the end, Stila Stay All Day® Dual-Ended Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner delivers on its promises: bold, intense color, reliable waterproof wear, and practical versatility with its dual-ended design. I’d recommend it to anyone who loves a sharp, dramatic eye look, wants longevity, and appreciates the convenience of having two tips in one pen. For those who prefer a lighter touch or are just learning to master liquid liners, a bit of practice might be needed, but the results are absolutely worth it.
Thanks so much for tuning in! You can find the link to purchase this liner in the description box or comments below. If you’ve already tried it, I’d love to hear your thoughts—drop a comment and share your experience! And until next time, stay beautiful inside and out!
If you like, I can also craft a shorter, punchier version optimized for high retention and social media engagement, keeping all the expert insights intact. Do you want me to do that?
Available to buy here:
