Available to buy here:
Welcome back to Beautyistic, where beauty meets expertise. Let’s set the scene for a second: imagine an eye look that transitions effortlessly from soft daytime shimmer to an elegant evening glow, all from a single product that’s as easy to apply as it is to wear. That’s exactly what we’re exploring today with the jane iredale Eye Shadow Crayon in the shade Moonstone. This is a shimmery, crayon-form eyeshadow designed to glide on smoothly, stay put, and deliver a blendable, smudge-resistant finish.
Now, at its core, this product is all about simplicity paired with sophistication. It comes in a crayon format, which is not only travel-friendly but also eliminates the need for multiple brushes. The Moonstone shade is a luminous, cool-toned shimmer that’s versatile enough to wear on its own or as a base to layer with powders for more dimension. Jane iredale, as a brand, is known for their clean beauty formulations, often leaning into skin-friendly ingredients that support long-term wear without irritation.
When I tested this crayon, I immediately noticed how smooth the application was. It didn’t tug or drag on the eyelid, which is important for the delicate eye area. I tried it two ways: first, swiped directly across the lid for a quick, one-and-done shimmer, and second, blended out with my fingertip to soften the edges. Both methods worked beautifully. The shimmer is noticeable without being glittery, which makes it suitable for everyday wear. Longevity-wise, it held up through a full workday without creasing badly, though I did find that using an eyeshadow primer underneath gave it more staying power.
Let’s break down the real-world pros and cons. On the positive side, the crayon format makes this extremely user-friendly, especially if you’re someone who struggles with brushes or just prefers quick makeup routines. The pigment payoff is impressive for a cream-based formula, and it blends well without losing its shimmer. On the downside, cream shadows like this can sometimes crease if your lids are on the oilier side, so primer might be a must. Also, because it’s a shimmery finish, it may not be ideal for those who prefer completely matte looks.
Quick pause—if you’re finding this review helpful so far, don’t forget to like, subscribe, and tap the bell icon so you never miss another Beautyistic review. Your support helps us keep delivering honest insights that matter.
When it comes to value for money, jane iredale sits in the premium category of beauty products, so the price tag reflects that positioning. However, compared to drugstore cream eyeshadows, the formulation here feels more refined, with a silkier glide and a more sophisticated shimmer. It competes well with higher-end brands like Laura Mercier’s Caviar Sticks but leans a little more toward a skin-loving, clean beauty ethos, which may justify the spend for those who prioritize healthier formulations.
Packaging-wise, the crayon feels sturdy and well-made. The twist-up mechanism works smoothly, and the cap stays secure, making it reliable to toss in a bag. Longevity in terms of the actual product? Given the richness of the pigment, a little goes a long way, so even though it’s a smaller format than a traditional eyeshadow palette, it doesn’t disappear quickly.
If you’re weighing alternatives, brands like NYX offer jumbo shadow pencils at a fraction of the cost, though the trade-off is often in wear time and finish refinement. If budget is a major factor, those could be a reasonable choice, but if you’re seeking something more elevated that aligns with clean beauty, jane iredale makes sense.
To wrap things up, the jane iredale Eye Shadow Crayon in Moonstone is a product that delivers on ease, elegance, and performance. It’s best suited for anyone who values quick application without sacrificing a polished finish, and especially for those who enjoy a luminous shimmer that’s wearable day to night. It’s not perfect for oily lids without primer, and it won’t appeal to matte lovers, but for most beauty enthusiasts, it’s a lovely balance of convenience and sophistication.
Thank you for spending time with me here at Beautyistic. If you’ve already tried the jane iredale Eye Shadow Crayons, I’d love to hear your thoughts—drop a comment below and let us know how it worked for you. The purchase link will be down in the description box if you’re curious to explore it further. Thanks for tuning in, and until next time, stay beautiful inside and out!
Available to buy here:
