Available to buy here:
Welcome to Beautyistic, where we explore the products that help you look and feel your absolute best. Today, we’re focusing on a simple but often overlooked hero in any beauty routine: the e.l.f. Shape & Stay Brow Pencil in a clear universal formula. It’s designed to tame, define, and hold your brows without adding color—making it suitable for any hair shade. Let’s see if it truly delivers the effortless, all-day groomed look it promises.
At first glance, this pencil is minimalist and approachable. It’s a clear wax formula weighing 0.6 oz, so it’s compact and travel-friendly. Its main role is to smooth and hold brow hairs in place while nourishing the skin with vitamin E, an antioxidant known for protecting and conditioning delicate skin. It’s also vegan, cruelty-free, and free from harsh chemicals like parabens and phthalates—so if you’re conscious about clean beauty, this definitely fits the bill.
Using it in my daily routine was straightforward. The pencil glides effortlessly over brow hairs without tugging or feeling sticky. I found it particularly handy in the mornings when I’m rushing but still want a polished look. Its lightweight texture allows for natural shaping, and it keeps hairs in place without stiffening or leaving a waxy residue. I tested it through a full workday and even during brief outdoor activities—it held up remarkably well, though heavier sweating or high humidity slightly reduces its staying power.
The strengths here are clear: the pencil is gentle, nourishing, and extremely easy to use. It doesn’t interfere with brow color if you’re layering it over a pencil or powder, and the universal clear formula eliminates the guesswork of matching shades. On the flip side, if you’re looking for a product that adds volume or fills sparse areas, this won’t provide that—it’s purely a styling and holding tool.
In terms of value, at its price point, it’s very accessible, especially considering its clean, vegan formulation and daily usability. It competes well with higher-end clear brow gels, offering similar hold without the premium cost. While some may prefer a clear gel for a thicker hold, the pencil format allows more precision for grooming individual hairs, which many beauty enthusiasts will appreciate.
The build is simple but effective—the pencil is solid, easy to twist, and won’t break in a makeup bag. There are no complaints about durability here; it’s the kind of product you can reach for daily without worrying about mess or waste.
If you’re exploring alternatives, there are clear brow gels at a slightly higher price point that may offer stronger hold or a glossy finish. However, for most users looking for a lightweight, no-fuss solution, this pencil hits the sweet spot.
So, is this review helpful to you? If so, please like, subscribe, and click the bell icon so other beauty lovers can find this video too. Your support helps us keep making honest reviews like this!
Overall, e.l.f. Shape & Stay Brow Pencil is a dependable, no-nonsense product for anyone seeking a polished brow look with minimal effort. It tames, nourishes, and holds without fuss, making it perfect for everyday use. If you’re someone who values a simple, clean, and effective brow tool, this is definitely worth trying.
Thank you for watching, and you can find the link to purchase this pencil in the description box below. If you’ve used this product, drop a comment and let us know your experience! Thanks for tuning in, and until next time, stay beautiful inside and out!
Available to buy here:
