Available to buy here:
Welcome to Beautyistic! If you’re on the hunt for an eyeliner that promises serious staying power without the usual smudging or fading, the REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner in Charcoal might just catch your eye. This pencil is designed to deliver bold, long-lasting lines that hold up all day—even in challenging conditions.
Right off the bat, what stands out about this liner is its claim to be waterproof, smudge-proof, and fade-proof for up to 24 hours. That’s a tall order for any eye makeup product, so I wanted to see how it really performs. The pencil itself is compact, with a built-in sharpener which is a smart convenience factor, plus a smudger on the opposite end for blending if you want a softer look.
The formula is richly pigmented, giving an intense charcoal shade that glides on smoothly without tugging at the delicate eye area. It feels lightweight, not cakey or drying, which is key when applying close to the waterline. I tested it through a full day—running errands, working at my desk, and even some light sweating—and I have to say, the liner did hold up remarkably well. No noticeable smudging or fading, and it stayed comfortably put on my waterline without irritation, which is always a concern with waterproof liners.
Application is straightforward. The pencil is soft enough to draw clean, precise lines yet firm enough to control the thickness of your stroke. Whether you prefer a subtle, defined lash line or a dramatic smoky effect using the smudger, it’s versatile. That built-in sharpener ensures your tip stays perfect for precision, which is often a pain point with pencil liners.
Now, no product is flawless. One minor downside is the size—at 0.01 oz, it’s a relatively small pencil, so for heavy daily users, it might not last as long as some might hope. Also, while the smudger is handy, it doesn’t produce a super dramatic blend like a dedicated brush would, but it’s fine for quick touch-ups.
In terms of value, REVLON is known for affordable quality, and this liner fits that mold. The longevity and performance you get easily justify the price point, especially considering it’s ophthalmologist tested and safe for waterline use. That’s important for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, adding peace of mind.
Compared to other pencil liners I’ve tried in this price range, this one holds its own exceptionally well in terms of staying power and comfort. It’s not quite as creamy as some high-end options, but the trade-off is better durability throughout the day without touch-ups.
Packaging is simple but practical—nothing fancy, but the built-in sharpener is a definite plus, eliminating the need to carry an extra tool. The pencil’s sturdy casing feels durable enough to toss in your makeup bag without worry.
Since I didn’t interact with REVLON’s customer support for this product, I can’t comment on that, but the brand generally has a solid reputation for responsiveness and quality assurance.
If budget is tight, there are cheaper eyeliners that claim waterproof wear, but they often fall short on smudge resistance or cause irritation. For those who want reliable, all-day wear with minimal fuss, this REVLON liner strikes a good balance between quality and price.
So, who is this eyeliner for? If you need a dependable pencil that won’t let you down through a busy day and prefer the convenience of an all-in-one tool with a built-in sharpener and smudger, this is a solid pick. It’s especially suited for anyone with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers thanks to its ophthalmologist testing and gentle formula.
Is this review helpful to you? If so, please like, subscribe, and click the bell icon so other beauty lovers can find this video too. Your support helps us keep making honest reviews like this!
Thanks so much for watching Beautyistic. You’ll find the link to grab your own REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner in the description or comments below. If you’ve already tried it, drop your thoughts down in the comments—I’d love to hear how it worked for you.
Until next time, stay beautiful inside and out!
Available to buy here:
