Available to buy here:
Hey beauties, welcome back to Beautyistic! I’ve got something today that’s perfect for those of us who love a dramatic, precise eye look without fussing over smudges—this is the Eyeko Black Magic Pencil Eyeliner in Intense Black. It’s a gel-formula pencil designed to give you buildable, soft definition with a semi-matte finish, and the best part—it’s completely vegan.
Right off the bat, this eyeliner comes in a sleek pencil form, making it easy to control for detailed work along the lash line or even for creating a subtle smoky effect. It claims to be blendable, so you can soften it with a brush or fingertip for that gradient look, and at 0.5 grams, it’s compact enough to toss in your makeup bag for touch-ups on the go.
When I put it to the test, I was impressed by the creamy gel texture—it glides on smoothly without tugging, which is always a win for sensitive lids. The pigmentation is rich, delivering a deep black in just one swipe, and it builds up nicely if you want an even more dramatic line. I tried it on my waterline and lash line, as well as smudging it lightly for a soft smoky effect, and it held up surprisingly well throughout the day. I did notice that while it’s blendable, it doesn’t budge once set, which is great for longevity but means you have to work fairly quickly if you’re creating a gradient look.
I’d say the pros are the intense pigmentation, creamy texture, and vegan-friendly formula. The blendable feature is a plus for smudging and softening lines, and it’s travel-friendly with its pencil design. On the flip side, it’s a small pencil, so you might find it runs out faster than traditional liners, and if you’re not quick with blending, it can set before you get your perfect gradient.
In terms of value, it sits in the mid-range for premium pencil eyeliners. Considering the quality, pigmentation, and cruelty-free formula, it’s a solid investment, though there are cheaper pencil liners that deliver decent black pigment but might not offer the same creamy, blendable experience. If you’re looking for a vegan option with intense black and a soft finish, this one definitely stands out.
Comparing it to other popular gel pencils, Eyeko’s formula is smoother and more forgiving on the delicate eye area than many drugstore options, which can sometimes drag or dry out quickly. It’s not quite as long-lasting as some waterproof pencils on the market, but for everyday wear, it’s excellent. The pencil itself feels well-made, the cap snaps securely, and the overall design is practical for travel or on-the-go touch-ups.
I haven’t had to contact Eyeko’s customer support, but the brand generally has a solid reputation for quality and responsiveness, which adds peace of mind when trying their products.
If you’re curious about alternatives, some other vegan black pencil liners might be slightly cheaper, but I’ve found they don’t always have the same balance of creaminess, blendability, and deep pigmentation that this one offers.
So, my final thoughts: Eyeko Black Magic Pencil Eyeliner delivers on its promise of intense black, soft definition, and blendable wear. It’s ideal for anyone who loves a dramatic, precise eye look with a vegan-friendly formula. If you’re a fan of smudgy, smoky effects as well as crisp lines, this pencil could easily become a staple in your makeup routine.
If this review is helpful to you, please like, subscribe, and click the bell icon so other beauty lovers can find this video too. Your support helps us keep making honest reviews like this!
Thanks so much for watching, and remember—the link to grab your Eyeko Black Magic Pencil is in the description or comments below. If you’ve tried it, I’d love to hear your thoughts—drop a comment and let me know your experience. Thanks for tuning in, and until next time, stay beautiful inside and out!
Available to buy here:
