Available to buy here:
Welcome back to Beautyistic, where we cut through the noise of the beauty world and get straight to what really matters in your routine. Let’s talk about a mascara that’s caught a lot of attention—tarte’s Maneater Waterproof Mascara in Black. This one promises to do it all: volume, curl, length, and staying power that holds up through sweat, humidity, and even a few tears. On paper, it’s a bold lash lover’s dream. But does it really deliver?
This mascara is designed with a waterproof formula that’s free from parabens, phthalates, SLS, oxybenzone, and fragrance. The brand positions it as safe for sensitive eyes while still giving extreme performance. Its selling point is that triple-threat effect: dramatic volume, serious length, and a lasting curl. It’s packaged in tarte’s signature luxe tube with a precision brush meant to catch every lash.
When I tested it in my daily routine, I wanted to see not just how dramatic it looked but also how comfortable it was to wear for hours. The brush is flexible enough to grab even the tiny corner lashes, and one coat gave a noticeable lift. Two coats pushed it into that bold, dramatic territory. It didn’t clump as much as I expected, though I’d say you have to apply carefully—layering too fast can make lashes stick together. The waterproof claim? That held up. I wore it on a particularly humid day, and there was no smudging, no flaking, and no dreaded raccoon eyes. Removal, however, was a little tougher—it needs a good oil-based remover to break down the formula.
Strengths are definitely in its staying power and the dramatic finish. It really does create that “false lash” look without the hassle of falsies. The wand design is also clever—it’s tapered, so you get both precision and volume in one swipe. On the flip side, if you prefer a softer, more natural lash, this might feel a bit too much. And like many waterproof mascaras, the removal process isn’t the gentlest—something to keep in mind if your lashes are delicate.
Is this review helpful to you? If so, please like, subscribe, and click the bell icon so other beauty lovers can find this video too. Your support helps us keep making honest reviews like this!
In terms of value, tarte positions itself in the higher-end category. For a waterproof mascara, it does justify the price more than most, given that it combines dramatic results with a clean formulation that avoids harsh ingredients. Compared to drugstore waterproof mascaras, the biggest differences are longevity, clump control, and brush design. However, if budget is a big factor, there are alternatives like L’Oréal Lash Paradise Waterproof that deliver great length and volume at a fraction of the price—though they don’t feel quite as refined in texture or wear.
The packaging feels sturdy, and the formula doesn’t dry out quickly in the tube, which is something I’ve noticed with some waterproof mascaras. Longevity-wise, this one stays consistent over weeks of use without losing its effectiveness. I haven’t had to reach out to tarte’s customer service for this product, but the brand does have a solid reputation for supporting their customers and standing behind their formulas.
So, where do I land on this? If you love bold, dramatic lashes that don’t budge no matter what your day throws at you, tarte Maneater Waterproof Mascara is worth the investment. It’s best suited for those who want long-lasting intensity without worrying about mid-day touch-ups. If you lean toward minimal, everyday makeup or have sensitive lashes that don’t tolerate waterproof formulas well, you might want to stick with a non-waterproof option.
Thank you so much for stopping by Beautyistic. If you’ve tried this mascara, share your experience in the comments—I’d love to hear how it worked for you. You’ll find the purchase link in the description or comments if you’re interested. Thanks for tuning in, and until next time, stay beautiful inside and out!
Available to buy here:
